A Fierce and Subtle Poison: Review

March 11, 2016 2016, 4 star books 9 ★★★★

A Fierce and Subtle Poison: ReviewA Fierce and Subtle Poison by Samantha Mabry
Published by Algonquin Young Readers on April 12, 2016
Genres: realistic fiction
Pages: 288 pages
Format: ARC
Source: Publisher
AmazonIndieboundBarnes & NobleGoodreads
Everyone knows the legends about the cursed girl--Isabel, the one the senoras whisper about. They say she has green skin and grass for hair, and she feeds on the poisonous plants that fill her family’s Caribbean island garden. Some say she can grant wishes; some say her touch can kill.

Seventeen-year-old Lucas lives on the mainland most of the year but spends summers with his hotel-developer father in Puerto Rico. He’s grown up hearing stories about the cursed girl, and he wants to believe in Isabel and her magic. When letters from Isabel begin mysteriously appearing in his room the same day his new girlfriend disappears, Lucas turns to Isabel for answers--and finds himself lured into her strange and enchanted world. But time is running out for the girl filled with poison, and the more entangled Lucas becomes with Isabel, the less certain he is of escaping with his own life.

I’m not quite sure what to write about Samantha Mabry’s debut, A Fierce and Subtle Poison. It’s an absorbing novel – magical realism isn’t generally my thing, but Mabry’s prose made this novel really work well for me. It is incredibly beautifully written, you all. I really enjoyed it and would recommend it. It’s been one of my favorite reads of the year so far.

Additionally, I started and finished A Fierce and Subtle Poison in less than 24 hours, so there’s that.

So. The book is a retelling (I think) of Hawthorne’s short story, Rappaccini’s Daughter, of which I remember … not a whit. The premise of the novel is something like this: there’s a legend about a cursed house in Old San Juan, where no birds will fly over. In it lives a cursed girl, with green skin and grass for hair. Lucas and his friends have both heard and told stories about this house since they were kids – and dared each other to throw wishes over the walls of the house, which it is said that the cursed girl will grant. But no one has ever seen her, although she sometimes appears in their dreams. One night, while out on a date, Lucas finds himself near the house, and thinks he sees her. Then, the girl Lucas is dating disappears, and he receives a note saying that the cursed girl knows where to find her.

Trying to unravel the mystery of the disappearing girls leads him to Isabel, the cursed girl. Isabel, who does not have green skin and grass for hair, is instead dying from a strange illness, which is only getting worse. She lives with her scientist father, who is obsessed with poisonous plants. View Spoiler » Lucas fantasizes about lifting the curse from the girl and the house and rescuing them both, but for the most part, these desires are pretty well shut down by the novel (and I really liked this, for the record – Isabel calls Lucas out on his desire to play the hero fairly early on in their meeting). Anyway, the two of them team up to figure out what has happened to the missing girls on the island.

What I liked best about the novel: the writing. I will read anything Samantha Mabry writes again, just because this is gorgeously written, honestly. Her prose is beautiful, and I felt like both the setting and Lucas’s narrative voice were really well developed. Our narrator, Lucas, is the son of a wealthy hotel developer and a Dominican woman (who left him when he was very young); there’s a lot of tension over Lucas and his father’s role in San Juan, and Lucas’s own sense of being an outsider. Isabel herself is also an outsider; because of her illness, she’s been locked away from the world, and most of her contact with it has come through the notes that people leave her.  Anyway – I liked how Mabry developed both of their characters, and I liked how the novel thoughtfully engages with the complexity of issues of identity and belonging. (As well as the importance of stories and shared history in forming a sense of community; I liked the contrast between Lucas and his father here.) There’s also a fairly hefty critique of American involvement in Puerto Rico through the characters of Lucas’s dad and Dr. Ford, too, I think.

What I liked least about the novel: I felt like there were some problems with pacing, especially towards the end of the novel, as I most wanted things to pick up. There’s an entire sequence where Lucas and Isabel are View Spoiler ».

Also, and this is not a fault of the novel – I wanted a little bit more from the ending. I think I’m okay with not knowing, but there are so many things that are left open. It’s probably a good sign, too, that I’ve been left thinking this much about the novel a week later. View Spoiler »

So. I really liked A Fierce and Subtle Poison and would strongly recommend it. Have you read it yet? Are you looking forward to it?

layla signature teal






9 Responses to “A Fierce and Subtle Poison: Review”

  1. Patty Cummings

    This book is on our TBR list in this house, me and my 2 daughters. I have heard very good things about it. We are reading SNowflake River at the moment, a great fantasy that reads like a non fiction which is why I love it so much. Ben Eliahu is the author. There are some fantastic reads this year, we are having great luck with books in our house.

  2. Tasya

    I’m really looking forward to read it. It’s sounds so interesting and it’s a retelling from a story I know nothing about! (I don’t even know what’s the original story is until you mentioned it above, so thank you so much!) I read the story and I wondered if the book would end up like the original story… I hope the pacing won’t be a problem for me though, since usually that’s what makes me dislike a book. Excellent review!
    Tasya recently posted…Remakes and Adaptations In General

  3. J.

    I’d been hearing a lot about this book and not thinking much of it, since I too am not a big fan of magical realism. But gorgeous prose is a huge plus–I’ll have to try it!

  4. Carina Olsen

    Yay :D Awesome review Layla. <3 I'm so glad you liked this book so much. Yay for gorgeous writing :) That's always the best. <3 But aw, I'm sorry the ending wasn't all that good. Sigh. I'm not planning on reading this book, though it do look pretty gorgeous :D Thank you for sharing about it. <3
    Carina Olsen recently posted…Waiting on Wednesday #231

    • Layla

      It really, really is a wonderful read. I feel like I’m still not quite sure how to think about it? But it’s unique for sure, fantastic (in both senses of the word) for sure, and I very much enjoyed reading it. I was totally absorbed by it and haven’t been able to stop thinking about it or trying to analyze it. There is seriously a lot to love there: the prose! the world-building! the character development! but mostly for me the prose.
      Layla recently posted…A Fierce and Subtle Poison: Review

    • Layla

      I really liked it! It’s a standalone novel, so there’s *resolution,* it’s just that I couldn’t stop thinking about what had happened in the book and was happening to certain characters and, like, WHAT IT ALL MEANT FOR THEM. I think it’s well worth your time, though, if you want to give it a try! I very much enjoyed this one.
      Layla recently posted…A Fierce and Subtle Poison: Review