by Lish McBride
At long last, it's here! This review contains some spoilers from the first book, so proceed at your own risk.
After killing the evil necromancer Douglas Montgomery in last year's hilarious Hold Me Closer Necromancer, Sam LaCroix has not only inherited Douglas' seat on their town's supernatural Council, but he's inherited his huge house, his shapeshifting cat butler James, and a small army of angry jam-loving gnomes as well. Just as he's settling into his new position as head of a very unusual household, however, his sister gets a nasty threat delivered to her door, and a sudden death changes everything. One thing a necromancer should always keep in mind, after all, is that just because someone's dead doesn't mean they stay that way.
It feels like we've been waiting for this sequel forever, and I'm so pleased to report that catching up with Sam and his crew is even more fun the second time around. Necromancing is more tautly plotted, faster, funnier, and full of even more madcap moments than the last time around.
Fun Necromancing Madness
A vengeful undead enemy? Check.
A werebear best friend? Check.
A harbinger of death who uses a Blackberry? Check.
A pointy-toothed, beef jerky-loving pygmy cupacabra? Check.
Stupidly entertaining gnome names like Chauncey the Devourer of Souls or Gnoman Polanski? Check.
Deceitful companions who just might be enemies? Check.
Aside from the zany one-liners and good-humored characters, there are also surprising moments of gravity that I really appreciated. Okay, so they happen to involve a sad zombie panda and throat-cutting, but still! I also got the wish I expressed in my review of Necromancer, which was that the antagonist would be more fully developed and nuanced. I loved the way the author explored his back story, and the climax and resolution felt properly serious and satisfactory, without being too somber for a book like this.
If I were to nitpick, I do wish a little more had been done with the awesome secondary cast. While I really liked the werewolf politics involving Sam's girlfriend Brid and her pack, I would love to have seen more done with the werebear, gnomes, etc. Right now they're mostly there for comic relief, while there was such a great opportunity to utilize them in the action and interpersonal scenes. I am, however, very glad that the book mostly loses the extraneous POVs that made the first book so disjointed. Necromancing focuses on two primary characters and allows us to get to know and appreciate both. Still, a third POV is inserted very late into the book at page 161, and then again at pages 278 and 296--and being that all of them total 11 pages, it seems as though the book would be much more streamlined and would have flowed much better if those parts had been reworked somehow.
But none of that really matters in the end, because jeez, this book is just so much fun. It's awesome when a sequel is even better than the original, and I'm hoping this means we'll not only see a trilogy, but that the third book will be the best book of all. If you enjoy humor with your young adult urban fantasy, this is a series that's not to be missed.
Publication Date: September 18, 2012
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars.
This review also appears on GoodReads. An advance copy was provided by the publisher.
P.S. Waffles make an appearance on page 50. Just in case you were wondering.
Win an ARC of Necromancing the Stone!
I would not give up my own copy of this book for anything. But thanks to our friends at Henry Holt, I do happen to have an extra galley, which we're giving away below! All you have to do is fill out the Rafflecopter form with your name and the reason why you are looking forward to this book.
As usual, this contest is open internationally to readers aged 13 and older, and you may earn extra entries for sharing the contest on Facebook, tweeting daily, etc. Good luck!
a Rafflecopter giveaway







I loved Hold Me Closer, Necromancer! Great review. I can't wait to read this!
ReplyDeleteThanks Paradox! I loved the first book too, and I'm very excited to see what everybody thinks of the sequel. I think it's even better than the first one.
DeleteI've heard so many great things about this one. I'm excited to read this.
ReplyDeleteThis book looks amazing. I can't wait to read it.
ReplyDeleteWelcome back :)
ReplyDeleteGreat review!
Thanks Danielle! And thanks again. :)
DeleteI really liked the first book, so I'm super excited for the sequel!
ReplyDeleteFirstly, I am so happy to see a new post on The Midnight Garden, yay!
ReplyDeleteSecondly great review! You've reminded me that I need to get Hold Me Closer like NOW! And I would like to win so I can read book 2 after book 1 :)
Good to see you back, Wendy!
Aw, thanks Mandee! Appreciate the welcome back. And omg, yes--you must read NECROMANCER asap. :)
DeleteI loved the first book so much; can't wait to read the second!
ReplyDeleteI've been waiting for the sequel of this book since Feb 2011, eagerly checking her blog and dogging Goodreads waiting for updates. I'm dying to have a copy of the new one! The wait is seriously KILLING me.
ReplyDeleteI've been waiting for this sequel to come out since Feb 2011. That time was spent seriously dogging Goodreads and McBride's blog for any update. Waiting for it to be released is seriously KILLING me!
ReplyDeleteIIII know, the wait has been insane! Just a few more weeks to wait, though, even if you don't end up winning the ARC here.
DeleteCan't wait for you to read it, Wendy. :)
Seems like a really interesting book, and I would absolutely love to read it.
ReplyDeleteI LOVED Hold Me Closer, Necromancer! It was honestly one of my favorite books of the year. I'd be thrilled to win this book!! And I'm absolutely dying to read it. Thanks so much for the awesome giveaway!!
ReplyDelete:) Wonderful review full of snark Wendy! I love the list and check part- so funny! I haven't read the first book so I should check it out sometime. Thanks for the giveaway!
ReplyDeleteRachel
Thanks Rachel! I rather liked my checklist, too. ;) Good luck!
DeleteHold me Closer, Necromancer was wonderful! I can't wait for the next installment. Great review, Wendy, I can't wait :D
ReplyDeleteIt WAS. And thanks Bonnie! I think you'll love this one, too. :)
DeleteI am about half way through Hold Me Closer...so I skimmed this review, BUT I can already tell I will be reading the sequel:)
ReplyDeleteYAY. :)
DeleteI feel so behind!! I still need to read Hold Me Closer, but I have it...so at least that's part 1 taken care of. This really sounds like a amazing read. I did enjoy the prequel, so I'm bound to enjoy the rest!
ReplyDeleteawesome review! you've really made me want to read both books! Thanks for the contest!
ReplyDeleteI hope you get a chance to read them soon, Carrie! Thank you. :)
DeleteI'm hearing great reviews for the Necromancer series. I don't want to feel left out. :-)
ReplyDeleteI've heard great reviews for the Necromancer series. I don't want to feel left out :-)
ReplyDeletemy 17-year-old daughter and I like fun fiction books-- she's becoming more adult and I think I'm becoming more of a kid even though I'm 47. I'm also a friend of Wendy Darling's and like the review.
ReplyDeletemy 17-year-old daughter really enjoys these types of books and I really enjoy adventuring through them with her! I think I'm becoming more of a kid. And I appreciate Wendy's review.
ReplyDeleteI knew a sequel was coming out but I wasn't sure when! Glad to hear this one is even better and I'm with you in hoping for a third to complete a trilogy.
ReplyDeleteI think anyone who loved the first book will love the second. :) The author confirmed she's working on book 3, but there is no release date yet.
DeleteSo glad you liked the second one (and thanks for hosting the giveaway!). I really liked the first, thought it had a cool premise, and was on the lookout for a second but didn't hear anything for the longest time so kind of gave up. Glad you posted about this or I probably wouldn't have known for the longest time!
ReplyDeleteI kind of went through the same thing, Scarlett. I feel like we waited for ages for a date, and then boom! There was date that was just a few months away. Which is a good thing. :D
DeleteI can't wait to read the next book in this series!
ReplyDeletecan't wait!
ReplyDeleteI LOVED the first book. I loved the relationship between the friends, especially loved Ramon and all of his zingers and one-liners. I cannot wait for more in the series. :D
ReplyDeleteI loved the first book, especially Ramon with his zingers and one-liners. I can't wait for the second book! :D
ReplyDeleteI need more necromancer/harbinger/dead head/hybrid humor. Can't wait!!!
ReplyDeleteLOVED Hold me closer, necromancer. Can't wait for more fun/harbingers/weres/witches! yay!
ReplyDeleteSo great to see you back, Wendy! I really liked Hold Me Closer, Necromancer - it was so refreshingly different from other paranormals and just didn't take itself too seriously, so I cannot wait to get my hands on the sequel. Plus: WAFFLES! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot for the giveaway!
Thanks Janina! I do love a good YA book with humor. :) I'm glad you're a fellow fan, hope you enjoy this one when it gets into your hands!
DeleteIt's so great to see you back, Wendy! I loved Hold Me Closer, Necromancer - it was so refreshingly different from others in its genre and just didn't take itself too seriously, so I cannot wait to get my hands on the sequel. Plus: WAFFLES!
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot for the giveaway.
I need to read the first book! It's been on my to-get list since forever. >__<
ReplyDeleteThe story sounds intriguing and I really like the cover art too.
Thanks for the giveaway & welcome back! I look forward to seeing your book reviews again.
ReplyDeleteI really need to read the first book, it's been on my to-get list for a LONG time. >_>
The story sounds intriguing and the cover art is fantastic!
Aw, thanks Lynn! I appreciate that.
DeleteAnd YES, do give NECROMANCER a try. It's a lot of fun. :)
Oh, this sounds like fun, but I need to read the first book before I jump to this one! Great review, I can't wait to read it :)
ReplyDeleteThis book sounds even better than the first one. I'm in.
ReplyDeleteIf you're a fan, I cannot recommend Lish McBride's Twitter and Facebook pages enough--she is very responsive to fans, and, not surprisingly, is a wonderful, kind, down-to-earth person.
ReplyDeleteLoved book one and was overjoyed when I heard there'd be a sequel. Now you say there'll be a third?! Life is wonderful :)
ReplyDeleteThank you for the chance to win! :)
ReplyDeleteCherry Mischievous
I enjoyed the quirkiness of the first book and Sam was so endearing. I want to find out about Sam's further adventures!
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed the quirkiness of the first book and Sam was so endearing. I want to read about Sam's further adventures!
ReplyDeleteWendy, I'll have to come back and read your review at a later date as I plan to read the first book very soon! I'm pleased to see a high rating though! I'm glad the sequel was a good one. :) Also, this book has one of my favourite covers ever. I love it!
ReplyDeleteWendy I am so glad to see you back in action! As hard as it is to do the best revenge is showing that the haters are not going to affect your life! I can't wait to read this book and I am so happy to read a review from you again, I have missed them!
ReplyDeleteThank you SO much, Desiree. I can't tell you how much your support means to me. xoxo
DeleteI didn't realize that was the sequel to Hold ME Necromancer. The covers are so different.
ReplyDeleteI've had the first book forever!!! I really need to read it. At least I won't have to wait for book 2.
Yes! This cover matches the new paperback edition of the first book, Karen, so I think that's why you were taken aback. It looks great in person, though--both of them.
DeleteNot waiting is a good reason to hold off on starting a series sometimes. ;)
By your review this book seams better than the first one I haven't read the first one and i'm going to start it. And thanks for this giveaway
ReplyDeletethanks for a great post and giveaway! This is the first I've heard of this series and it sounds awesome :)
ReplyDeleteLOVED the first book; I managed to get a friend not only to read it, but to include it on her Gothic lit class. I will most definitely be teaching *Hold Me Closer* as soon as I get a chance; meanwhile, I am DYING to read *Necromancing the Stone* [pun mostly intended].
ReplyDeleteWow, that's awesome kittens! NECROMANCER did have a rather Gothic feel to it, and I think the sequel has even more of that. Good luck, I hope you get your hands on it soon. :)
DeleteGreat review! Can't wait till the book comes out!
ReplyDeleteI always love original takes on Urban Fantasy. Can't wait for this sequel.
ReplyDeleteI absolutely adored Hold Me Closer, Necromancer so I'm so excited there's a sequel coming out soon!
ReplyDeleteI loved everything about Sam. His quick wit, his snarky attitude, and his devotion to his friends. I can't wait to read how he handles his newfound powers. And I adore that title! :D
ReplyDeleteI've heard such great things about these books! I haven't read the first one, but having a copy of book two would certainly be an incentive to read this series sooner rather than later. :-p
ReplyDeleteI read the first book and loved it. For a long time I thought it was a standalone and am "sooo excited" (this is said in my head in the voice of Marjorie of FatFighters, Little Britain) that the sequel is here - or nearly here, if it could be mine a bit earlier in September, it would be greatly appreciated.
ReplyDeleteThis RaffleCopter is not my kind of bag though. I shared on FB, but it won't accept it. Actually, most of the time I do not enter RaffleCopter competitions, because it is so tedious, but I am sure it makes things easy for you guys to tally the entries. :-)
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry you've had trouble with RaffleCopter, HellyBelly. If you share it on your FB wall, I know you well enough to trust that you've done so, though, so no worries on that front. :)
DeleteReally great review!
ReplyDeleteLove the plot:)
I truly enjoyed the first book, and can't wait to read this one. This has got to be highly anticipated after reading the first.
ReplyDeleteI just picked up Hold Me Closer, and I am eager to start a new series. Thanks for the giveaway!
ReplyDeleteI read the first book and I can't wait for this one. So glad to see that it rocks and I loved the secondary characters in that one as well. I'm thinking they will have more to do with the story if they had POV pages in this one. Sweet!
ReplyDeleteI haven't read this series at all, but now I want to! Added to my TBR list.
ReplyDeleteI can't wait for this book! I loved the first book in the series and after your awesome review, I am even more excited!
ReplyDeleteI can't wait for this book! I loved the first book in the series and after your awesome review, I am even more excited!
ReplyDeleteFree books are always good! and I appreciate a good sense of humor.
ReplyDeleteI've not heard of this book before, but it sounds funny. and I always appreciate a good sense of humor.
ReplyDeleteI'm a new follower and just wanted to say thanks for this review.
ReplyDeleteI sat down with our Macmillan rep today and when we hit this book, I knew to get it, as well as Hold Me Closer, Necromancer as I know many customers who will love them.
That's great to hear, Cate--I think it's always great when there's YA with a male POV, and YA with humor, too! I hope you enjoy them when you get them into your store.
DeleteHold Me Closer, Necromancer was so fun and hilarious!! I've been waiting for ever for the next book to come out and it's almost here!! :D
ReplyDeleteWhen I first started reading Hold Me Closer, Necromancer... I thought it was the weirdest book ever! And then all the sudden: I just loved it! I am so excited to read Necromancing the Stone. :)
ReplyDeleteSo glad to see you back at it!
ReplyDeleteSo glad you're back at it!
ReplyDeleteI loved Hold Me Closer. Hmm.. craving some waffles suddenly.
ReplyDeleteGlad to see you back, wendy!
werebear best friend - I want one!
ReplyDeletewerebear best friend - I want one!
ReplyDeleteI liked the humor, totally up my ally. Also it was refreshing to have a male POV. I'd love to get my hands on the second book, because I liek to laugh. :D
ReplyDeleteThe MC was hilarious. I laughed out loud several times. It was such a fun read!
ReplyDeleteOkay, will now need to go read Hold Me Closer, Necromancer. Sounds like a good read.
ReplyDeleteI would love to win because I haven't read this series yet and would like to! It looks like something I would really like! Thanks for the chance to win!
ReplyDeleteI like to win since I have never heard or read this book. It sounds awesome.
ReplyDeleteI loved HMCN, and Lish totally rocks for sending me this great t-shirt I won in one of her contests! She even included cute stickers for my kid!
ReplyDeleteI just started the first book and think it's hilarious. I can't wait to read the next one!
ReplyDeleteJust finished the first one, and now want to read the second ASAP! I very much enjoyed the characters and humour in the first book, but felt it suffered a little from "setting up a series" syndrome, with a huge number of dangling plot threads. From your review it sounds like many of these are addressed in the sequel (and also that there are fewer POV shifts, HOORAY), so now I'm doubly interested!
ReplyDelete